Our performance and improvement
Our caseload
This year we handled an exceptional and unbudgeted incoming level of complaints – a 23% increase on the previous year. This exceeded our previous highest annual volume of incoming complaints, but there is no discernible common cause or pattern to this year’s increase.
We believe we are seeing the impact of rising consumer expectations and the use of AI in our higher incoming, rising complexity, more challenging resolution discussions and rising numbers of appeals. That appears to be in line with what other similar organisations are experiencing, and we’re continue to monitor these developments, to share our experiences and to learn from others.
As well as increased workload, the higher number of appeals against our decisions has contributed to a significant rise in legal costs this year.
Despite the high incoming number of complaints, we closed significantly more complaints than last year and ended the year with fewer complaints in hand. Much of this was achieved due to changes in our eligibility process which led to significant efficiency gains. We also continued a strong focus on early resolution which saves time and effort for everyone and reduces the period of stress a complaint can often bring for both parties.
This work has also advanced us towards what will be possible under the new 2025 Act, helping prepare us for the full transition when that legislation is commenced.
Failures to respond
One issue which continues to affect timely resolution of complaints is solicitors not co-operating with our investigations. This includes not providing information or a file when we make a statutory request for it because we need it to consider a complaint.
This has been a key focus for us over the year, as in previous years. We continue to test an approach to proceeding to investigate the complaint in the absence of the file, where that is possible and does not detriment the complainer. However, while this has been possible in a small number of cases, it masks and does not address the root cause of the issue.
We have continued to raise legal actions in the Court of Session to obtain files. This has contributed to continued high legal costs this year.
We have also been discussing this issue with the Lord President and the Law Society of Scotland, and this year we agreed joint work to tackle the issue. The Society has made changes to the correspondence it sends to practitioners who do not respond to us, and the process and timescales for issuing such correspondence, which we are grateful for. We also issued a joint statement to the profession to highlight the impact of delays and failures in compliance, and further communications are planned.
It has been agreed that a joint report by the SLCC and the Law Society will be submitted to the Lord President in December 2026 to assess progress and its effect on compliance rates.
Despite these efforts no statistical progress has been made during the year. The percentage of cases that need a reminder after the initial Section 17 request has increased to 27%, over 10 percentage points up on last year. The percentage of cases where we do not get a response after a Section 17 reminder, and so have to instruct lawyers, has increased this year, but over the last 3 years has remained 5% or lower after a peak of 16% in 2019/2020.
We will continue to monitor progress and assess whether the work with the Law Society begins to improve compliance during the coming year. We are also looking at how we can use new powers, coming from the 2025 Act, to tackle this issue in the future.